Compare and Contrast Characters - Free Printable

Problem Overview:

The task is to compare and contrast the characters from the classic version of "The Three Little Pigs" with a modern version. The goal is to fill in the T-Chart provided, indicating whether each point is a comparison (CP) or a contrast (CT). Finally, reflect on what was learned by comparing the stories.

---

Solution Approach:

1. Understand the Classic Version:
- Little Pig 1: Builds a house of straw.
- Little Pig 2: Builds a house of sticks.
- Little Pig 3: Builds a house of bricks.
- Big Bad Wolf: Blows down the houses of the first two pigs but fails to blow down the third pig's brick house.

2. Consider Possible Modern Versions:
- Modern versions might introduce changes such as:
- Different materials for the houses (e.g., plastic, cardboard).
- A more friendly or less menacing Big Bad Wolf.
- Additional elements like teamwork or problem-solving skills among the pigs.

3. Fill in the T-Chart:
- Compare similarities (CP) and identify differences (CT) between the classic and modern versions for each character.

4. Reflect on Learnings:
- Summarize insights gained from comparing the two versions.

---

Filled T-Chart:

#### Little Pig 1
- Classic Version: Builds a house of straw.
- Modern Version: Builds a house of a different material (e.g., plastic).
- Contrast (CT): Material used for the house is different.
- Classic Version: Gets blown away by the wolf.
- Modern Version: Might escape or find a way to survive.
- Contrast (CT): Outcome differs due to changed circumstances or abilities.

#### Little Pig 2
- Classic Version: Builds a house of sticks.
- Modern Version: Builds a house of a different material (e.g., cardboard).
- Contrast (CT): Material used for the house is different.
- Classic Version: Gets blown away by the wolf.
- Modern Version: Might team up with other pigs or use technology to survive.
- Contrast (CT): Outcome or approach differs.

#### Little Pig 3
- Classic Version: Builds a house of bricks.
- Modern Version: Builds a house of a different material (e.g., concrete or metal).
- Contrast (CT): Material used for the house is different.
- Classic Version: Survives because the brick house is sturdy.
- Modern Version: Might still survive but with additional features (e.g., security systems).
- Comparison (CP): Both survive due to a strong house structure.

#### Big Bad Wolf
- Classic Version: Acts aggressively, blowing down houses.
- Modern Version: Might be portrayed as less menacing or even helpful.
- Contrast (CT): Character motivation or behavior changes.
- Classic Version: Fails to blow down the brick house.
- Modern Version: Might have a different reason for not succeeding (e.g., moral lesson).
- Comparison (CP): Still does not succeed in blowing down the strongest house.

---

Reflection:

#### What did you learn by comparing the stories?
By comparing the classic and modern versions of "The Three Little Pigs," I learned that:
1. Adaptability of Stories: Modern versions often adapt the core plot to include contemporary elements, such as new materials or updated themes.
2. Character Development: Characters can evolve; for example, the Big Bad Wolf might be given a softer or more complex personality in modern adaptations.
3. Moral Lessons: While the classic version emphasizes the importance of hard work and planning (building a sturdy house), modern versions might focus on creativity, teamwork, or problem-solving.
4. Cultural Relevance: Modern adaptations often reflect current values or societal changes, making the story more relatable to contemporary audiences.

---

Final Answer:

\boxed{
\begin{array}{|c|c|c|}
\hline
& \textbf{Classic Version: The Three Little Pigs} & \textbf{Modern Version: The Three Little Pigs} \\
\hline
\text{Little Pig 1} & \text{Builds a house of straw. (CP)} & \text{Builds a house of plastic. (CT)} \\
& \text{Gets blown away. (CP)} & \text{Escapes or survives differently. (CT)} \\
\hline
\text{Little Pig 2} & \text{Builds a house of sticks. (CP)} & \text{Builds a house of cardboard. (CT)} \\
& \text{Gets blown away. (CP)} & \text{Teams up or uses technology. (CT)} \\
\hline
\text{Little Pig 3} & \text{Builds a house of bricks. (CP)} & \text{Builds a house of concrete. (CT)} \\
& \text{Survives due to sturdy house. (CP)} & \text{Survives with additional features. (CP)} \\
\hline
\text{Big Bad Wolf} & \text{Acts aggressively. (CP)} & \text{Is less menacing or helpful. (CT)} \\
& \text{Fails to blow down the brick house. (CP)} & \text{Fails for a different reason. (CT)} \\
\hline
\end{array}
}
\boxed{\text{Reflection: Adaptability of stories, character development, moral lessons, cultural relevance.}}