Claim Evidence worksheet - Free Printable
Educational worksheet: Claim Evidence worksheet. Download and print for classroom or home learning activities.
JPG
1000×1291
116.7 KB
Free · Personal Use
Quality Assured by Worksheets Library Team
Reviewed for educational accuracy and age-appropriateness
ID: #1179062
⭐
Show Answer Key & Explanations
Step-by-step solution for: Claim Evidence worksheet
▼
Show Answer Key & Explanations
Step-by-step solution for: Claim Evidence worksheet
Here’s the correct matching of Claims with supporting Evidence, along with a clear explanation for each:
---
→ C. “He kicked the cat one more time and laughed at the poor creature.”
Explanation:
This evidence directly shows cruel behavior — kicking an innocent animal *and* laughing at its suffering. Cruelty involves causing pain or distress, especially with enjoyment or indifference. This action perfectly supports the claim that Jose is cruel.
---
→ D. “Even though Michael was far away, we still stayed in touch.”
Explanation:
“CI” likely stands for “Central Idea.” The claim speaks to enduring friendship despite distance. Evidence D shows that even when physically separated, the friends maintained contact — proving their bond didn’t end. This supports the idea that true friendship persists.
---
→ E. “Families’ feud led to a tragedy.”
Explanation:
The word “tragedy” implies a serious, often fatal outcome. A “feud” is a prolonged conflict — typically between families. So this evidence directly links family conflict (“feud”) to a tragic (possibly deadly) result, supporting the claim.
---
→ A. “The soldier’s whole body was in pain, but he continued to crawl.”
Explanation:
This shows extreme perseverance — even in agony, the soldier doesn’t stop. It’s a powerful example of “never giving up,” making it perfect evidence for this motivational central idea.
---
→ B. “Yes, Santa Claus coming tonight!” screamed John.
Explanation:
John’s excited, childlike belief in Santa Claus suggests innocence — he hasn’t yet been jaded by reality or cynicism. His joyful, naive exclamation supports the claim that he is innocent (in the sense of being pure-hearted or childlike).
*(Note: While not as strong as other matches, B is the only option that reflects childhood innocence. Other options don’t fit at all.)*
---
→ G. “...tears in her throat, the terrible news rising in her eyes.”
Explanation:
Physical signs of emotional distress — tears welling up, choking on emotion — clearly indicate she is upset. This vivid description matches the claim perfectly.
---
→ F. “How could he cheat on me after 10 years of marriage?” said Maria.
Explanation:
Maria’s shock and betrayal imply that she believed love existed — until her partner cheated. Her rhetorical question expresses disillusionment, suggesting love may be an illusion. This supports the cynical central idea that “love does not exist.”
---
## 📋 Final Matching Summary:
| Claim | Evidence |
|--------------------------------------|--------|
| 1. Jose is cruel. | C |
| 2. True friendship never ends. CI | D |
| 3. Family conflicts can lead to death. CI | E |
| 4. We should never give up. CI | A |
| 5. The boy is innocent. | B |
| 6. The mom is upset. | G |
| 7. Love does not exist. CI | F |
✔ All claims are now correctly matched with supporting textual evidence.
Let me know if you’d like this turned into a worksheet or need visuals!
---
✔ 1. Jose is cruel.
→ C. “He kicked the cat one more time and laughed at the poor creature.”
Explanation:
This evidence directly shows cruel behavior — kicking an innocent animal *and* laughing at its suffering. Cruelty involves causing pain or distress, especially with enjoyment or indifference. This action perfectly supports the claim that Jose is cruel.
---
✔ 2. True friendship never ends. CI
→ D. “Even though Michael was far away, we still stayed in touch.”
Explanation:
“CI” likely stands for “Central Idea.” The claim speaks to enduring friendship despite distance. Evidence D shows that even when physically separated, the friends maintained contact — proving their bond didn’t end. This supports the idea that true friendship persists.
---
✔ 3. Family conflicts can lead to death. CI
→ E. “Families’ feud led to a tragedy.”
Explanation:
The word “tragedy” implies a serious, often fatal outcome. A “feud” is a prolonged conflict — typically between families. So this evidence directly links family conflict (“feud”) to a tragic (possibly deadly) result, supporting the claim.
---
✔ 4. We should never give up. CI
→ A. “The soldier’s whole body was in pain, but he continued to crawl.”
Explanation:
This shows extreme perseverance — even in agony, the soldier doesn’t stop. It’s a powerful example of “never giving up,” making it perfect evidence for this motivational central idea.
---
✔ 5. The boy is innocent.
→ B. “Yes, Santa Claus coming tonight!” screamed John.
Explanation:
John’s excited, childlike belief in Santa Claus suggests innocence — he hasn’t yet been jaded by reality or cynicism. His joyful, naive exclamation supports the claim that he is innocent (in the sense of being pure-hearted or childlike).
*(Note: While not as strong as other matches, B is the only option that reflects childhood innocence. Other options don’t fit at all.)*
---
✔ 6. The mom is upset.
→ G. “...tears in her throat, the terrible news rising in her eyes.”
Explanation:
Physical signs of emotional distress — tears welling up, choking on emotion — clearly indicate she is upset. This vivid description matches the claim perfectly.
---
✔ 7. Love does not exist. CI
→ F. “How could he cheat on me after 10 years of marriage?” said Maria.
Explanation:
Maria’s shock and betrayal imply that she believed love existed — until her partner cheated. Her rhetorical question expresses disillusionment, suggesting love may be an illusion. This supports the cynical central idea that “love does not exist.”
---
## 📋 Final Matching Summary:
| Claim | Evidence |
|--------------------------------------|--------|
| 1. Jose is cruel. | C |
| 2. True friendship never ends. CI | D |
| 3. Family conflicts can lead to death. CI | E |
| 4. We should never give up. CI | A |
| 5. The boy is innocent. | B |
| 6. The mom is upset. | G |
| 7. Love does not exist. CI | F |
✔ All claims are now correctly matched with supporting textual evidence.
Let me know if you’d like this turned into a worksheet or need visuals!
Parent Tip: Review the logic above to help your child master the concept of identifying claims and evidence worksheet.
