Match each claim with the supporting evidence and picture.
Worksheet showing claims and evidence with images and text for matching exercise.
JPG
1000×1291
80.3 KB
Free · Personal Use
Quality Assured by Worksheets Library Team
Reviewed for educational accuracy and age-appropriateness
ID: #774268
⭐
Show Answer Key & Explanations
Step-by-step solution for: Claim and evidence worksheet
▼
Show Answer Key & Explanations
Step-by-step solution for: Claim and evidence worksheet
Let's solve this step-by-step by matching each claim with the correct evidence statement and picture that supports it.
---
We are given:
- Four claims on the left.
- Four evidence statements with pictures at the bottom.
- We need to match each claim with the evidence (statement + image) that best supports it.
---
#### Claim 1: June is the best month of the year.
- The picture shows "Happy June!" with a beach scene.
- This suggests summer fun, possibly related to warm weather or vacation.
- Matching Evidence: "It is a good month to go to the beach." → This directly supports why June might be great (beach season).
- Image: Beach with kids playing → matches the evidence.
✔ So, Claim 1 → Evidence: "It is a good month to go to the beach." (with beach picture)
---
#### Claim 2: Dogs make the best pets.
- Picture shows a dog next to a crossed-out cat.
- Suggests preference for dogs over cats.
- Matching Evidence: "For example, they are interactive, playful, and even let you dress them up." → This describes positive traits of dogs.
- Image: Dog in superhero costume → supports the idea of dressing them up.
✔ So, Claim 2 → Evidence: "For example, they are interactive, playful, and even let you dress them up." (with dog in costume)
---
#### Claim 3: Pizza is the best food in the world.
- Picture shows a slice of pizza.
- Matching Evidence: "Pizza is fun because you can eat it with your hands." → explains why pizza is enjoyable.
- Image: Girl eating pizza with her hands → supports this point.
✔ So, Claim 3 → Evidence: "Pizza is fun because you can eat it with your hands." (with girl eating pizza)
---
#### Claim 4: Apples are gross.
- Picture shows a bitten apple.
- Matching Evidence: "Because there are so many varieties of apples, you never know how an apple will taste." → this implies unpredictability in taste, which could support the idea that apples are unpredictable or unpleasant.
- But wait — this seems weak as support for "apples are gross."
- However, among all options, this is the only one about apples.
- The other evidence doesn’t relate to apples.
So, even though it’s not strong, it's the only logical match.
✔ So, Claim 4 → Evidence: "Because there are so many varieties of apples, you never know how an apple will taste." (with three apples)
> Note: This is a bit of a stretch. A stronger argument would be something like “They’re too sour” or “I don’t like the texture,” but since we're limited to the given choices, this is the only possible match.
---
| Claim | Evidence Statement & Picture |
|----------|-------------------------------|
| June is the best month of the year. | It is a good month to go to the beach. (Beach image) |
| Dogs make the best pets. | For example, they are interactive, playful, and even let you dress them up. (Dog in costume) |
| Pizza is the best food in the world. | Pizza is fun because you can eat it with your hands. (Girl eating pizza) |
| Apples are gross. | Because there are so many varieties of apples, you never know how an apple will taste. (Three apples) |
---
- We matched each claim to the evidence that logically supports it.
- The key is finding a logical connection between the opinion (claim) and the reason (evidence).
- Even if some evidence is weak (like the apple one), we use the best available option from the list.
This exercise teaches students to identify supporting evidence for opinions, a critical skill in writing and reasoning.
---
Step 1: Understand the Task
We are given:
- Four claims on the left.
- Four evidence statements with pictures at the bottom.
- We need to match each claim with the evidence (statement + image) that best supports it.
---
Step 2: Analyze Each Claim
#### Claim 1: June is the best month of the year.
- The picture shows "Happy June!" with a beach scene.
- This suggests summer fun, possibly related to warm weather or vacation.
- Matching Evidence: "It is a good month to go to the beach." → This directly supports why June might be great (beach season).
- Image: Beach with kids playing → matches the evidence.
✔ So, Claim 1 → Evidence: "It is a good month to go to the beach." (with beach picture)
---
#### Claim 2: Dogs make the best pets.
- Picture shows a dog next to a crossed-out cat.
- Suggests preference for dogs over cats.
- Matching Evidence: "For example, they are interactive, playful, and even let you dress them up." → This describes positive traits of dogs.
- Image: Dog in superhero costume → supports the idea of dressing them up.
✔ So, Claim 2 → Evidence: "For example, they are interactive, playful, and even let you dress them up." (with dog in costume)
---
#### Claim 3: Pizza is the best food in the world.
- Picture shows a slice of pizza.
- Matching Evidence: "Pizza is fun because you can eat it with your hands." → explains why pizza is enjoyable.
- Image: Girl eating pizza with her hands → supports this point.
✔ So, Claim 3 → Evidence: "Pizza is fun because you can eat it with your hands." (with girl eating pizza)
---
#### Claim 4: Apples are gross.
- Picture shows a bitten apple.
- Matching Evidence: "Because there are so many varieties of apples, you never know how an apple will taste." → this implies unpredictability in taste, which could support the idea that apples are unpredictable or unpleasant.
- But wait — this seems weak as support for "apples are gross."
- However, among all options, this is the only one about apples.
- The other evidence doesn’t relate to apples.
So, even though it’s not strong, it's the only logical match.
✔ So, Claim 4 → Evidence: "Because there are so many varieties of apples, you never know how an apple will taste." (with three apples)
> Note: This is a bit of a stretch. A stronger argument would be something like “They’re too sour” or “I don’t like the texture,” but since we're limited to the given choices, this is the only possible match.
---
✔ Final Matching:
| Claim | Evidence Statement & Picture |
|----------|-------------------------------|
| June is the best month of the year. | It is a good month to go to the beach. (Beach image) |
| Dogs make the best pets. | For example, they are interactive, playful, and even let you dress them up. (Dog in costume) |
| Pizza is the best food in the world. | Pizza is fun because you can eat it with your hands. (Girl eating pizza) |
| Apples are gross. | Because there are so many varieties of apples, you never know how an apple will taste. (Three apples) |
---
📝 Explanation:
- We matched each claim to the evidence that logically supports it.
- The key is finding a logical connection between the opinion (claim) and the reason (evidence).
- Even if some evidence is weak (like the apple one), we use the best available option from the list.
This exercise teaches students to identify supporting evidence for opinions, a critical skill in writing and reasoning.
Parent Tip: Review the logic above to help your child master the concept of identifying claims and evidence worksheet middle school.