1. Mr. Trapper was shot by Mr. Hunter at 12:00 midnight, as confirmed by the bullet matching Mr. Hunter’s gun and Mr. Hunter’s own statement about shooting an intruder.
2. Mr. Trapper’s body was dragged, indicating he was killed before being moved, which aligns with the bloodstains found outside Mr. Hunter’s apartment.
3. Mr. Trapper was dead for one hour when found, meaning he was killed at 12:00 midnight and discovered at 1:00 a.m.
4. Miss Fisher saw Mr. Trapper go to Mr. Hunter’s building at 11:55 p.m., placing him there just before the shooting.
5. The elevator operator saw Mr. Trapper go to Mr. Doe’s room at 12:25 a.m., but since Mr. Trapper was already dead by then, this sighting is impossible unless the operator is lying or mistaken.
6. Mr. Hunter disappeared after the murder, suggesting guilt and an attempt to evade capture.
7. Mr. Hunter had threatened to kill Mr. Trapper, providing motive.
8. The knife in Miss Fisher’s yard with Mr. Doe’s fingerprints may be a red herring or planted evidence, as Mr. Doe’s involvement is not supported by other clues.
9. The elevator operator’s DWI convictions suggest possible unreliability, making the 12:25 a.m. sighting suspect.
10. Mr. Hunter’s claim that private citizens have the right to keep handguns is irrelevant to the crime but may indicate he expected to use his gun without consequence.
11. Mr. Trapper’s wife frequently left the building with Mr. Doe, which may imply a relationship but does not connect them to the murder.
12. The only bullet fired from Mr. Hunter’s gun matches the one that killed Mr. Trapper, confirming Mr. Hunter as the shooter.
13. Since Mr. Trapper was dead by 12:00 midnight and seen going to Mr. Hunter’s building at 11:55 p.m., the logical conclusion is that Mr. Hunter killed him shortly after arrival.
14. The dragging of the body suggests Mr. Hunter moved it to create confusion or mislead investigators.
15. Mr. Hunter is the murderer, as all physical and circumstantial evidence points to him: motive, opportunity, weapon match, disappearance, and the timeline of events.
Parent Tip: Review the logic above to help your child master the concept of murder mystery worksheet.