AUTHORS POINT OF VIEW WORKSHEET online exercise for - Free Printable

Problem: Analyze the provided text about the Titanic and answer the questions related to point of view.

#### Text Summary:
The text describes the tragic sinking of the Titanic, highlighting its history, the events leading up to the disaster, and the consequences. The author expresses a critical viewpoint by pointing out the lack of preparedness (e.g., insufficient lifeboats) and mistakes made during the emergency.

---

Question 1: What is the author’s viewpoint on the Titanic?

#### Solution:
The author's viewpoint on the Titanic is critical and judgmental. The text emphasizes the ship's lack of preparedness for emergencies, specifically noting:
- The Titanic was not equipped with enough lifeboats.
- The crew was not adequately prepared for a disaster.
- Mistakes were made during the evacuation process (e.g., lifeboats were not filled to capacity).

The author also suggests that if the Titanic had been better prepared, more lives could have been saved. This indicates a belief that human error and negligence contributed significantly to the tragedy.

#### Text Evidence:
1. "However, the ship was not equipped with enough lifeboats in case disaster struck."
2. "And disaster did strike. The crew was not prepared."
3. "This was a senseless mistake that cost even more people their lives."
4. "If the Titanic had been more prepared with lifeboats and procedures for disaster, more lives would have been saved."

---

Question 2: How would the text be different if it had been told from a survivor’s point of view rather than this author’s point of view?

#### Solution:
If the text were told from a survivor’s point of view, it would likely include:
1. Personal experiences and emotions: A survivor would describe their own feelings, actions, and observations during the disaster. For example, they might talk about the panic, the struggle to find a lifeboat, or the fear of drowning.
2. Detailed accounts of specific events: A survivor might provide firsthand details about what happened in their immediate surroundings, such as the sounds of the ship breaking apart, the chaos on deck, or interactions with other passengers and crew members.
3. A more emotional tone: The text would likely convey stronger emotions, such as fear, desperation, or relief at surviving. It might also express gratitude toward those who helped them escape or grief over lost loved ones.
4. Focus on survival strategies: A survivor might highlight how they managed to survive, such as finding a lifeboat, jumping into the water, or being rescued by another ship.

#### Comparison to the Author’s Point of View:
The author’s point of view is more analytical and critical, focusing on systemic issues like insufficient lifeboats and crew preparation. In contrast, a survivor’s account would be more personal and emotional, providing a first-hand perspective of the disaster.

---

Question 3: How do you feel about the Titanic? How does your viewpoint compare to the author’s viewpoint?

#### Solution:
This question is subjective and depends on the reader's personal feelings. However, here is a possible response:

- My Feelings About the Titanic:
- I feel a mix of sadness and fascination. The Titanic represents both a marvel of engineering and a cautionary tale about human hubris and negligence. Its story is tragic, but it also serves as a reminder of the importance of safety measures and preparedness.

- Comparison to the Author’s Viewpoint:
- My viewpoint aligns with the author’s in that I also believe the disaster could have been mitigated with better preparation. However, while the author focuses primarily on criticism, my perspective includes a sense of awe at the ship’s grandeur and historical significance. I also feel empathy for the victims and survivors, which adds an emotional layer to my understanding of the event.

#### Example Response:
"I feel a combination of sadness and fascination about the Titanic. On one hand, it is heartbreaking to think about the loss of so many lives due to poor planning and mistakes. On the other hand, the Titanic represents a remarkable feat of engineering and stands as a symbol of human ambition. My viewpoint aligns with the author’s in recognizing the need for better safety measures, but I also feel a deeper emotional connection to the stories of the people involved, which the author does not explicitly address."

---

Final Answers:

1. Author’s Viewpoint: The author’s viewpoint is critical, emphasizing the Titanic’s lack of preparedness and the mistakes that led to the tragedy.
- Text Evidence:
- "The ship was not equipped with enough lifeboats."
- "The crew was not prepared."
- "This was a senseless mistake that cost even more people their lives."
- "If the Titanic had been more prepared, more lives would have been saved."

2. Survivor’s Point of View: The text would be more personal and emotional, focusing on firsthand experiences, survival strategies, and the intense emotions of the disaster.

3. My Feelings and Comparison:
- I feel a mix of sadness and fascination. My viewpoint aligns with the author’s in recognizing the need for better safety measures but also includes empathy for the victims and survivors, which the author does not explicitly address.

---

Final Answer Box:

1. Author’s Viewpoint: Critical, emphasizing lack of preparedness and mistakes.
- Text Evidence: Provided above.
2. Survivor’s Point of View: More personal, emotional, and focused on firsthand experiences.
3. My Feelings: Sadness and fascination; aligns with the author’s critique but includes empathy for victims and survivors.

\boxed{See detailed responses above.}