Chart illustrating the total valence electrons and Lewis structures for common molecules.
Table showing molecules (CH₄, NH₃, H₂O, CO₂, HCN), their total valence electrons, and Lewis structures.
PNG
913×829
183.6 KB
Free · Personal Use
Quality Assured by Worksheets Library Team
Reviewed for educational accuracy and age-appropriateness
ID: #479082
⭐
Show Answer Key & Explanations
Step-by-step solution for: 4.1.6 Lewis Structures | DP IB Chemistry: HL Revision Notes 2016 ...
▼
Show Answer Key & Explanations
Step-by-step solution for: 4.1.6 Lewis Structures | DP IB Chemistry: HL Revision Notes 2016 ...
Actually, there is an error in the Lewis structure shown for HCN in the table.
Let’s analyze and correct it step by step.
---
## ✔ Step 1: Verify Total Valence Electrons for HCN
- Hydrogen (H): 1 valence electron
- Carbon (C): 4 valence electrons
- Nitrogen (N): 5 valence electrons
Total = 1 + 4 + 5 = 10 valence electrons → ✔️ Correct as shown.
---
## ✔ Step 2: Determine Correct Lewis Structure for HCN
HCN is a linear molecule: H — C ≡ N
- Hydrogen can only form one bond (it has only 1 valence electron).
- Carbon needs 4 bonds to complete its octet.
- Nitrogen needs 3 bonds + 1 lone pair to complete its octet.
So the bonding should be:
- Single bond between H and C
- Triple bond between C and N
That gives:
- H — C (single bond) → uses 2 electrons
- C ≡ N (triple bond) → uses 6 electrons
- Remaining 2 electrons go on nitrogen as a lone pair
✔ So total electrons used: 2 (H–C) + 6 (C≡N) + 2 (lone pair on N) = 10 electrons → matches!
---
## ✘ Problem with the Given Lewis Structure
The image shows:
```
H : C : N :
```
This implies:
- Single bond between H and C (OK)
- Single bond between C and N (WRONG — should be triple)
- Lone pairs shown as dots around atoms, but not correctly placed.
In this drawing:
- Carbon only has 2 bonds (to H and N), so only 4 electrons → violates octet rule.
- Nitrogen has only 1 bond and 3 lone pairs → 8 electrons, which is OK, but carbon is incomplete.
- Also, total bonds shown use only 4 electrons (2 single bonds), leaving 6 electrons as lone pairs — but that doesn’t match the correct bonding.
---
## ✔ Correct Lewis Structure for HCN
```
H — C ≡ N :
↑
(with 2 electrons as lone pair on N)
```
Or drawn with dots:
```
H — C ::: N :
↑
(the three colons represent triple bond; the two dots on N are the lone pair)
```
More clearly:
```
H - C ≡ N
:
```
(Where “:” represents the lone pair on nitrogen)
---
## 📝 Summary of Correction
| Molecule | Total Valence e⁻ | Correct Lewis Structure |
|----------|------------------|--------------------------|
| HCN | 10 | H—C≡N: (with lone pair on N) |
> ⚠️ The structure shown in the table is incorrect. It does not satisfy the octet rule for carbon and misrepresents the bonding.
---
## 💡 Why This Matters
Lewis structures must:
1. Account for all valence electrons.
2. Satisfy the octet rule (for C, N, O, etc.) — except H, which follows duet rule.
3. Minimize formal charges (in this case, HCN has zero formal charges in the correct structure).
---
✔ Final Answer:
The Lewis structure for HCN in the table is incorrect. The correct Lewis structure is H—C≡N:, where carbon is triple-bonded to nitrogen, and nitrogen has one lone pair. This satisfies the octet rule for C and N, and uses all 10 valence electrons.
Let’s analyze and correct it step by step.
---
## ✔ Step 1: Verify Total Valence Electrons for HCN
- Hydrogen (H): 1 valence electron
- Carbon (C): 4 valence electrons
- Nitrogen (N): 5 valence electrons
Total = 1 + 4 + 5 = 10 valence electrons → ✔️ Correct as shown.
---
## ✔ Step 2: Determine Correct Lewis Structure for HCN
HCN is a linear molecule: H — C ≡ N
- Hydrogen can only form one bond (it has only 1 valence electron).
- Carbon needs 4 bonds to complete its octet.
- Nitrogen needs 3 bonds + 1 lone pair to complete its octet.
So the bonding should be:
- Single bond between H and C
- Triple bond between C and N
That gives:
- H — C (single bond) → uses 2 electrons
- C ≡ N (triple bond) → uses 6 electrons
- Remaining 2 electrons go on nitrogen as a lone pair
✔ So total electrons used: 2 (H–C) + 6 (C≡N) + 2 (lone pair on N) = 10 electrons → matches!
---
## ✘ Problem with the Given Lewis Structure
The image shows:
```
H : C : N :
```
This implies:
- Single bond between H and C (OK)
- Single bond between C and N (WRONG — should be triple)
- Lone pairs shown as dots around atoms, but not correctly placed.
In this drawing:
- Carbon only has 2 bonds (to H and N), so only 4 electrons → violates octet rule.
- Nitrogen has only 1 bond and 3 lone pairs → 8 electrons, which is OK, but carbon is incomplete.
- Also, total bonds shown use only 4 electrons (2 single bonds), leaving 6 electrons as lone pairs — but that doesn’t match the correct bonding.
---
## ✔ Correct Lewis Structure for HCN
```
H — C ≡ N :
↑
(with 2 electrons as lone pair on N)
```
Or drawn with dots:
```
H — C ::: N :
↑
(the three colons represent triple bond; the two dots on N are the lone pair)
```
More clearly:
```
H - C ≡ N
:
```
(Where “:” represents the lone pair on nitrogen)
---
## 📝 Summary of Correction
| Molecule | Total Valence e⁻ | Correct Lewis Structure |
|----------|------------------|--------------------------|
| HCN | 10 | H—C≡N: (with lone pair on N) |
> ⚠️ The structure shown in the table is incorrect. It does not satisfy the octet rule for carbon and misrepresents the bonding.
---
## 💡 Why This Matters
Lewis structures must:
1. Account for all valence electrons.
2. Satisfy the octet rule (for C, N, O, etc.) — except H, which follows duet rule.
3. Minimize formal charges (in this case, HCN has zero formal charges in the correct structure).
---
✔ Final Answer:
The Lewis structure for HCN in the table is incorrect. The correct Lewis structure is H—C≡N:, where carbon is triple-bonded to nitrogen, and nitrogen has one lone pair. This satisfies the octet rule for C and N, and uses all 10 valence electrons.
Parent Tip: Review the logic above to help your child master the concept of bonding worksheet 5 lewis structures.